I have to cast a vote for the Earl of Sandwich too. My favorite place to eat in Downtown. It's our Go-To restaurant on our first day at WDW. We generally do the Downtown thing on our first day so we don't burn a ticket on a short arrival day. It gives a great "first day immersion" experience, a great meal at the Earl and just soak up the Disney atmosphere. Then we are really ready for a "Full-On" Disney day on day 2!!!!
There are many great places to dine at WDW, but one of our favorites I think doesn't get nearly enough credit. The Earl of Sandwich (at Downtown Disney) is out of this world, and you can use your Disney dining plan there.
Resorts
2017 AKL-Jambo House (May)
2017 Old Key West (Apr)
2016 Port Orleans Riverside (Oct)-Hurricane Matthew!!
2016 Old Key West (Aug)
2016 CBR (Jul)
2016 Art of Animation (May)
2015 Ft. Wilderness Campground (Oct)
2014 Sherwood Forest RV Park (Nov)
2013 Pop Century (Jul)
2012 Hyatt Regency Grand Cypress (Jul)
2011 Radisson Lake Buena Vista (Aug)
2010 Pop Century (Nov)
2009 PO Riverside (Jul)
2008 Pop Century (Apr)
2006-2007 FL residents: Hunters Creek 8 miles from the parks!!
2005 All Star Sports (Jul)
2005 PO Riverside/CBR/CSR (Apr)