Offline
Joined: 11/22/2012
Posts: 1120
JMUDukz wrote:Eeyore wrote:angels444 wrote:We have always gone with the Deluxe plan , but by day 10 we were rolling around the park, we were so full. This time we went we had no plan at all. Our lunch at Le Cellier was 130.00, Cape May ( all you can eat seafood) was 108.00 with tip , BOG quick service 40 something dollars and is naming just a few. The real stickler for me was the snacks. We use to get 2 free snacks a day , but with plus you get 1 snack a day. This trip we would go to the ice cream cart and the Mickey bars are 3.75. I had to question if I really wanted to have that ice cream bar. Cupcakes were anywhere from 3.50 to 4.50 needless to say I did not do my cupcake crawl this trip. We felt that free Dining plus would be enough for us in the future and would be a great bargain.
I agree! I don't know if I would go without it! I wouldn't want to eat at QS locations the entire time while there. Plus, some of the QS options are basically junk food. They offer a *few* salads and such, but I couldn't eat that everyday for a week. I enjoy having variety. I love the snacks too! I try to get something fun like mickey bar or popcorn on main street!
Hmmmm....you guys are making me rethink not doing the DP. May have to do my calculations again!!
I def. think it's personal preference, but it just makes sense to me. However, I could see it not being worth it if we stayed in a DVC 2 bedroom with full kitchen. You could cook all of your food instead of eating out. We normally get an appt. when eating out and coffee afterwards so it fits our dining style.
Offline
Joined: 07/19/2013
Posts: 1562
Eeyore wrote:JMUDukz wrote:Eeyore wrote:angels444 wrote:We have always gone with the Deluxe plan , but by day 10 we were rolling around the park, we were so full. This time we went we had no plan at all. Our lunch at Le Cellier was 130.00, Cape May ( all you can eat seafood) was 108.00 with tip , BOG quick service 40 something dollars and is naming just a few. The real stickler for me was the snacks. We use to get 2 free snacks a day , but with plus you get 1 snack a day. This trip we would go to the ice cream cart and the Mickey bars are 3.75. I had to question if I really wanted to have that ice cream bar. Cupcakes were anywhere from 3.50 to 4.50 needless to say I did not do my cupcake crawl this trip. We felt that free Dining plus would be enough for us in the future and would be a great bargain.
I agree! I don't know if I would go without it! I wouldn't want to eat at QS locations the entire time while there. Plus, some of the QS options are basically junk food. They offer a *few* salads and such, but I couldn't eat that everyday for a week. I enjoy having variety. I love the snacks too! I try to get something fun like mickey bar or popcorn on main street!
Hmmmm....you guys are making me rethink not doing the DP. May have to do my calculations again!!
I def. think it's personal preference, but it just makes sense to me. However, I could see it not being worth it if we stayed in a DVC 2 bedroom with full kitchen. You could cook all of your food instead of eating out. We normally get an appt. when eating out and coffee afterwards so it fits our dining style.
Yeah, it definitely comes down to personal situations. It works out great for some and not so much for others. Unfortunately, I think a lot of people just blindly go for the dining plan *assuming* it's a great deal. I think the moral of the stories here is to do some number crunching and analyze your eating habits and preferences and then make the decision.
Offline
Joined: 11/22/2012
Posts: 1120
KenJ wrote:Eeyore wrote:JMUDukz wrote:Eeyore wrote:angels444 wrote:We have always gone with the Deluxe plan , but by day 10 we were rolling around the park, we were so full. This time we went we had no plan at all. Our lunch at Le Cellier was 130.00, Cape May ( all you can eat seafood) was 108.00 with tip , BOG quick service 40 something dollars and is naming just a few. The real stickler for me was the snacks. We use to get 2 free snacks a day , but with plus you get 1 snack a day. This trip we would go to the ice cream cart and the Mickey bars are 3.75. I had to question if I really wanted to have that ice cream bar. Cupcakes were anywhere from 3.50 to 4.50 needless to say I did not do my cupcake crawl this trip. We felt that free Dining plus would be enough for us in the future and would be a great bargain.
I agree! I don't know if I would go without it! I wouldn't want to eat at QS locations the entire time while there. Plus, some of the QS options are basically junk food. They offer a *few* salads and such, but I couldn't eat that everyday for a week. I enjoy having variety. I love the snacks too! I try to get something fun like mickey bar or popcorn on main street!
Hmmmm....you guys are making me rethink not doing the DP. May have to do my calculations again!!
I def. think it's personal preference, but it just makes sense to me. However, I could see it not being worth it if we stayed in a DVC 2 bedroom with full kitchen. You could cook all of your food instead of eating out. We normally get an appt. when eating out and coffee afterwards so it fits our dining style.
Yeah, it definitely comes down to personal situations. It works out great for some and not so much for others. Unfortunately, I think a lot of people just blindly go for the dining plan *assuming* it's a great deal. I think the moral of the stories here is to do some number crunching and analyze your eating habits and preferences and then make the decision.
Yes. I would also recommend looking at menus of ALL the places you plan to visit. Add up everything you would want to order. This helps in figuring that out.
Offline
Joined: 07/19/2013
Posts: 1562
JMUDukz wrote:Eeyore wrote:Allie wrote:If the regular dining plan (1 snack, 1 QS, 1 TS) offered the option to do an app OR dessert, it would probably make sense for us to do it. The way it is right now, however, is a waste because we'd end up spending more out of pocket for apps and then skipping the dessert. Deluxe dining is an option but it seems like too much food for hubby and I who normally split meals.
I totally agree! I would love it if they offered that. Sometimes I don't feel like eating any dessert, but may have wanted an app instead OR I could get app, DH get dessert! It's a win/win! 
This would be perfect if it offered the choice. I am a fan of dessert, but at some places, like BOG where the dessert is pretty much cupcakes, it's not really worth it. C'mon Disney!! Give the people what they want!! Apps or desserts!! Freedom of choice!! 
You know, that simple change would be all it would take to make it work for many more people. 