Ah...the classic Italian battle. Here's another dining comparison thread for everyone to weigh in on!
My thoughts? Mama's is probably better food, overall. But the service is often poor, and the setting is nothing to write home about.
Tony's Town Square is a fun idea, and I love the Lady and the Tramp references throughout. The food isn't great, but you CAN sit on the patio and catch a parade now and again...
Your turn!