WDWFG Superlatives: Best Signature Dining

I love Yachtsmen! I also love Cali Grille so it was tough but I have never had a bad meal at the YSH. The service is always good and I just love it there.
I think I have a menu and some pics I will have to look.

I haven't been to any of these! I really wish I could have an opinion...

Are you going to try any on the honeymoon trip?

I chose Citricos. The food is usually great, but the chairs are super comfy and that tips the scales in my opinion for some reason?!?

@Caitie--where are you guys eating in August?

The California Grill and Citricos can battle it out on any given trip. Depending on what soups and cheeses they have. I think the best time I've had was at Cali Grill though, so I gave them the nod. I think my average may be better at Citricos though, because I've had some bad service at CG.

Oooooo, tough to choose! I haven't been to all of them, and I liked all the ones I've been to......but I chose Citricos, due to food, service, presentation, and atmosphere......

I am torn between the Filet and the Short Ribs. I always wish I could get 1/2 of each.

We aren't trying any that are on this list (mostly because we have a very limited budget)

We are doing The Wave, Le Cellier, Boma, Ohana, Marakesh, and one of the French restaurant, Biergarten and Boma breakfast

Those are all good. Actually I've never eaten at the Wave but I love the rest. Le Cellier is like "signature" dining except without the price and with Canadians!

I really enjoy some of the "signature" places, but I'd rarely say they're worth the extra money. I usually have one of my best meals at Liberty Tree Tavern and it costs less than 1/2 of California Grill.

I don't have a ton of experience with any of them, but I've had a good meal at almost all.

I've heard a lot of good things about the Flying Fish, but I'm not a big seafood guy.