I've decided to add another comparison thread, for the other comparisons so far see:
http://www.wdwforgrownups.com/forum/index.php?tid=327
I was in a discussion recently about the Pot Roast at Liberty Tree Tavern vs. 50's Prime Time. I like both of these restaurants but LTT has become a must-do, while i haven't been visiting 50's Prime Time. Both of these have had a serious downturn for me -- LTT no longer puts the little friend onion strips on the Pot Roast and 50's Prime Time no longer serves their "Herb Cheese" which was 1/2 of the reason I went.
I think both have a good Pot Roast. For me the killer dish at Liberty Tree Tavern is the Fried Cheese. I could eat a ton of that stuff and their Clam Chowder is a favorite as well. 50's Prime Time is fun and I'd definitely recommend it to anyone, but I go to LTT much more often. How about you guys?