Thinking of doing a NO ADR's trip, end of this month, yet grabbing a couple nice dinners. 4 night BWV, we go to WDW 3 times a year, and only 2 of us.
As WDW Pros, here's what we do currently. Add some more suggestions!
+ Go off season!
+ We recognize the places that are usually booked and don't waste our time trying.
+ Quick service is much more relaxing, less crowds, when you eat an EARLY breakfast and EARLY lunch
+ EPCOT resorts and AKL Boma always have openings for 2 (short wait)
+ Polynesian and GF are usually booked, but you can sit at the bars and "appetizers hop"
+ TREX and Rainforest always have openings, and probably most of the restaurants at DTD
+ Always enjoy the hunt for food, we're at Disney! Have a fall back place to eat. Pack your cargo pants with tots.
From your replies (Updated 1/12/2015)
+ Swan and Dolphin. Il Mulino (Miss Mikki)
+ Marrakesh at EPCOT, Olivia's at Old Key West (crazycatperson)
+ Crews Cup Lounge in the Yacht Club (The Colonel)
+ Make same day ADR's (jhugo)