Tony's or Liberty Tree Tavern

Tuff question to answer for me. I like both of them but it depends on they type of food you want. Liberty tree is served family style and is all you can eat. For that reason, I usually pick Tony's.

Liberty Tree. I am not a fan of Tony's. We've gone there before and I wasn't impressed with the food.

Yeah that one is tuff, but I may have to pick Tony's because of the view during the parades if you can get the right seating. The food in both places is very good in my opinion. I know several people have stated they had not to good of an experience at Tony's, but we've always had a great time there

I've only eaten at Liberty Tree Tavern and enjoyed the lunch I had there last year. I have a lunch ADR at LTT and dinner ADR at Tony's this year.

I would have to throw my vote to LTT rather than Tony's, just a personal choice.

LTT. My choice has nostalgia behind it. That was the first place I ate at Disney on my first trip when I was 7. I kept the menu for years! Wonder if I still have it somewhere?...

That's a cool story! I hope you do still have that menu..that's a great collectors item.

If I remember correctly, it had Mickey dressed in Patriot garb on the front, and it was printed on that antique-looking paper. I really will have to hunt for it. Mom and I have been discussing scrapbooking, and it would be so fun to do albums with all the pics we've amassed through the years. I don't think we'd fill volumes actually, since most of our trips are daytrips, but it would be fun to have them all together...instead of in bins under the spareroom bed!

Id say the roast because Turkey makes me sleepy........

I've only had the turkey and it was good.

The pot roast consistently gets raving reviews.

I've only had the turkey but ohh it's delicious. I don't eat red meat so I can't really give an unbiased opinion.